The All-Robio Award is given to the best players at each position. Running backs and wide receivers each receive two awards since we start four total players at those positions every week. And we don’t stop at a First Team. We also hand out Second-Team and Third-Team honors. That means 24 players can earn an All-Robio Award each season.
So, who is the best at consistently delivering All-Robio players?
Well, I have the most all-time with 72 total award winners, while Griff is second with 69.
But that’s not exactly a great indicator since we’re the only two original league members still in the league.
How about average?
Again, it’s me (2.67 per year) and Griff (2.56) leading the pack. Averages are usually a pretty good way to determine who’s best. But I wanted to dig a little deeper because not all positions are created equal. Obviously, an All-Robio quarterback is more valuable than an All-Robio kicker.
So, I came up with something I call the “Proficiency” average.
In this formula, I weigh QB, RB and WR more heavily than TE and D/ST, which are worth more than kickers. I also value First-Team selections more than Second-Team selections, with both worth more than Third-Team honors.
You can see the full math at the bottom if you’re into that sort of thing.
So, who has the best Proficiency Average in league history?
ARPs = All-Robio Players
You can find the entire history of All-Robio players HERE.
#12 JEFF GREENBLATT — 6.06
In 18 seasons, Greenblatt has produced just five First-Team ARPs, seven Second-Teamers and 12 Third-Teamers.
Of his 24 career ARPs, his eight running backs are the most he’s produced at any single position. Yet, to this day, Jeff has never produced a First-Team QB, TE or D/ST. In fact, he’s never even produced a Second-Team tight end. The only tight end to earn even a Third-Team award was McBride last season.
I’ll give Jeff this: he’s gotten a lot better at delivering ARPs.
In his first seven years in the league, he produced just four total ARPs. Over his last 13 seasons, he’s produced 21.
#11 DON VOZZOLA — 6.96
Don produced three ARPs this past season, the most he’s ever had in a single year. None were First-Team players, but he’s now produced 36 ARPs in 25 seasons. That’s an average of 1.44 per year, which ranks 11th in the league and puts him ahead of Jeff’s 1.33.
Don has produced 13 First-Team award winners, eight Second-Teamers and 15 Third-Teamers. Twenty-three of his 36 ARPs have been running backs (13) or wide receivers (10), while kickers account for roughly 20% of his total.
Oddly enough, in 25 seasons, Don has never produced an All-Robio quarterback. Not a First-Team QB. Not a Second-Team QB. Not even a Third-Team QB. Let’s see if that changes in 2026.
#10 ROB MASTERSON — 7.83
Rob has produced 37 total ARPs in 24 seasons, including nine First-Team players, 18 Second-Teamers and 10 Third-Teamers.
He does have 15 total All-Robio running backs, which ranks fourth in league history.
His nine career First-Team ARPs are the third-lowest total on this list, ahead of only Michael (6) and Jeff (5). Five of those nine have been running backs. Unfortunately, like Don and Jeff below him, Rob has produced zero First-Team quarterbacks or tight ends during his 24-year run in the league.
#9 RICH BURRIER — 8.67
Rich has 37 total ARPs, the same as Masterson. Both joined the league in 2022, but Rich has 16 First-Team players compared to Rob’s nine, which is why his Proficiency Average is higher.
Overall, Rich has produced 16 First-Team players, 13 Second-Teamers and eight Third-Teamers.
He’s also one of the most balanced owners on this list, producing at least four ARPs at every position. His 11 running backs lead the way.
Rich has produced four career First-Team All-Robio quarterbacks, second most behind Colby.
He’s also had four First-Team running backs, although two came courtesy of Tomlinson in 2005 and 2006. He’s had just two since: Freeman in 2015 and Jacobs in 2022.
It took him 21 years to produce his first First-Team All-Robio wide receiver, but he’s now had two in his last four years: Hill in 2022 and Chase in 2024.
If he’s looking for an area to improve, he might want to work on his D/ST selections. Burrier hasn’t had an All-Robio D/ST in the last 14 years.
#8 ERIC VOZZOLA — 9.80
Eric has 47 ARPs in 25 seasons, an average of 1.88 per year. That’s not a particularly impressive number, but he makes up for it by being very good at producing First-Team players.
Of his 47 total ARPs, 19 are First-Team, 17 are Second-Team and 11 are Third-Team.
He’s produced at least six ARPs at every position except running back.
In fact, Eric is the only person in league history who has never produced a First-Team All-Robio running back. He’s had just two Second-Team backs, Matt Forte in 2011 and Ray Rice in 2012, along with three Third-Teamers. The most recent was Joe Mixon in 2023.
On the flip side, Eric has produced 14 All-Robio wide receivers, third most in league history. Seven of those were First-Team selections, which ranks second all-time, one behind Bob.
#7 RICH CALDERON — 10.13
You’d think someone as successful as Calderon has been in this league would rank higher on this list.
Yet here we are.
Overall, he has 47 ARPs in 23 seasons and averages 2.04 per year, which ranks fifth in the league. The problem? Too many of those are Third-Team awards, which drags down his Proficiency rating.
Calderon has produced 19 First-Team players, eight Second-Teamers and 20 Third-Teamers, the second-most in league history. He has produced a First-Team player at every position, but he’s had some pretty significant droughts.
At quarterback, he became the first person to have a First-Team QB three straight years, Brees in 2008 and 2009, followed by Rodgers in 2010. But he hasn’t had one since. That’s 15 years and counting.
He has four All-Robio tight ends, but all four came courtesy of Antonio Gates between 2004 and 2010. He hasn’t had one since , which is another 15-year drought.
It took him eight years to produce his first All-Robio wide receiver. Then he had six in nine years from 2011-2018. Now he’s gone seven years without one.
At running back, Calderon earned a First-Team award with Barkley in 2024. That was just his third career First-Team running back. The others were Ahman Green in 2003 and LeSean McCoy in 2013.
#6 MICHAEL EVANGELIST — 10.71
Michael has only been in the league for seven seasons, but he’s managed to produce at least one ARP in six of them. The lone exception was 2023.
Officially, he has 13 ARPs, an average of 1.86 per season, which ranks seventh in the league. But he gets bumped up a spot in the Proficiency Average because he’s been particularly good at producing First-Team players.
He has six First-Team selections, five Second-Teamers and just two Third-Team players. The only thing missing from the résumé is an All-Robio quarterback. Michael has yet to deliver a QB who has earned a First, Second or Third-Team award.
#5 MATT NEATOCK — 11.26
Back in 2017, Matt produced two First-Team running backs in one year, Bell and Gurley, becoming the first person to accomplish that. He followed it up with Barkley in 2018. Since then, though, he’s produced just one more First-Team back: Henry in 2024.
Oddly enough, he can’t seem to replicate that success at any other position. His last First-Team wide receiver and D/ST came in 2015. His last First-Team kicker was Bironas in 2007. His last First-Team quarterback was Carson Palmer in 2005.
And he’s never had a First-Team tight end.
Still, Matt has produced 48 ARPs in 23 seasons, including 15 First-Team awards, 18 Second-Teamers and 15 Third-Teamers.
Overall, he has 20 All-Robio running backs, tied for the most in league history. He’s tied with Griff, who has been in the league four more years, meaning Matt actually has the best average of All-Robio running backs in league history.
His seven First-Team running backs are second most all-time, behind me, although I have four more seasons in the league.
But Matt’s biggest claim to fame might be this: 77% of his All-Robio players have been QBs, RBs or WRs.
That’s the highest percentage in the league: 36 of his 47 ARPs.
#4 GRIFF COOMER — 12.07
Overall, Griff has produced 67 All-Robio players in 27 seasons, the second-most in league history.
His 2.48 per-season average is tied for second best. He’s also produced 22 First-Team players, 27 Second-Teamers, a league best, and 18 Third-Teamers.
So why is Coomer only fourth on this list?
Because a lot of his All-Robio success has come at the secondary positions: TE, kicker and D/ST. Those positions are weighted slightly less in the Proficiency formula.
Of his 22 First-Team award winners, half have come at TE, PK or D/ST. Of his 67 total All-Robio players, 29 have come from those three positions, which is a league high.
Last year, he produced his second career All-Robio quarterback with Lamar, but he hasn’t had a First-Team running back since 2017 and hasn’t had a First-Team wide receiver since 2011. Hell, he hasn’t had a First-Team tight end since 2005.
He does have 18 career All-Robio running backs, third most in league history. But only two of those 18 have come in the last nine seasons, and both were Third-Teamers: Elliott in 2020 and White in 2023.
#3 COLBY HALL — 12.50
Colby has always been solid at producing All-Robio players, but he’s really turned it on lately, producing nine ARPs over the last three seasons, including four First-Team selections.
Overall, he has 54 ARPs in 22 seasons, averaging 2.45 per year. That’s actually the second-best average among non-original league members, behind only Robio and Griff.
He has 19 First-Team players, 22 Second-Teamers and 13 Third-Teamers. His 22 Second-Team selections are second most in league history, behind only Griff.
At quarterback, it took Colby 14 years to deliver his first First-Team All-Robio QB… Russell Wilson. Now he’s dominating the category, producing five of the last nine First-Team quarterbacks, including Josh Allen last year.
At running back, he had just two First-Teamers through his first 19 seasons. He’s now had two in the last three, including Taylor last year. Wide receiver is a different story. He had three First-Teamers between 2005 and 2009, but hasn’t had one since. He also hasn’t had an All-Robio kicker since 2010.
At tight end, Kelce delivered back-to-back First-Team awards in 2017 and 2018. Those remain the only two First-Team tight ends Colby has ever produced, although he has added four Second-Teamers.
#2 ROBIO MURRAY — 13.41
My 76 career All-Robio players are a league best, thanks in part to 27 years in the league. My 2.81 ARPs per season is also a league high. Yet somehow, I failed to secure the top spot.
Why?
Too many Third-Team players.
I have 27 First-Team All-Robio players, including eight running backs, 14 Second-Team players and 35 Third-Team players, which is 15 more than the next person. I also have 27 ARPs from the secondary positions: TE, PK and D/ST.
Since 2019, I’ve produced at least one First-Team award winner at every position except D/ST. My last First-Team D/ST was the Bears back in 2005. Of course, someone could argue that I benefited from being in the league before the meat of the teams joined.
Fair.
But while I did produce 12 All-Robio players in my first four seasons, I’ve also produced 12 in my last four years in the league. So I’m not exactly living off the glory days.
#1 BOB CASTRONE — 13.48
The man. The myth. The legend.
Bob has produced 57 total ARPs in 23 seasons. His 2.48 average is tied with Griff for second best. But the distribution is what really separates him.
Of those 57 players, 21 were First-Team, 19 were Second-Team and 17 were Third-Team. Even better for Bob, 40 of his 57 All-Robio players have been QBs, RBs or WRs. That’s 70%.
Only Neatock has a higher percentage at 77%, but Bob has produced more of them overall, which is why he sits atop the Proficiency rankings.
And then there’s wide receiver. Bob has produced 22 All-Robio wide receivers, including eight First-Team wideouts. Both numbers are easily the most in league history.
Since 2014, Bob has produced at least one All-Robio receiver in every season except 2023. That’s an absurd level of consistency. And apparently, that’s what it takes to beat me.
THE MATH
The Proficiency formula assigns more value to the positions that have a greater impact on fantasy football, while also rewarding higher-tier All-Robio selections.
FIRST TEAM
- QB — 9 points
- RB — 9 points
- WR — 9 points
- TE — 6 points
- D/ST — 6 points
- PK — 3 points
SECOND TEAM
- QB — 6 points
- RB — 6 points
- WR — 6 points
- TE — 4 points
- D/ST — 4 points
- PK — 2 points
THIRD TEAM
- QB — 3 points
- RB — 3 points
- WR — 3 points
- TE — 2 points
- D/ST — 2 points
- PK — 1 point